ACH vs Card Rent Payments

On a $1,500 rent, an ACH payment costs $1 to $2.35 in fees and a card payment costs $44.85 to $52.35. Rent apps charge a flat amount for ACH and a percentage for cards, so the gap grows with the rent. This guide shows the fee at $800, $1,500, and $2,500 on four apps, using fees read from their pages on 21 November 2026.

Affiliate disclosure: Landlord Grid earns a commission when you sign up through some links on this page.

The Fee Formulas

AppACHCard
Innago$22.99%
RentRedi$13.1% + $0.30
Baselane$23.49%
Buildium Essential$2.35 incoming2.99%

TenantCloud lists tenant paid ACH fees of $1.50 to $1.95 by plan. We did not confirm its card fee on its own pages, so it stays out of the card tables.

Fees on Three Rents

Each cell is the fee on one payment. Checked 21 November 2026.

Rent of $800

AppACHCard
Innago$2.00$23.92
RentRedi$1.00$25.10
Baselane$2.00$27.92
Buildium Essential$2.35$23.92

Rent of $1,500

AppACHCard
Innago$2.00$44.85
RentRedi$1.00$46.80
Baselane$2.00$52.35
Buildium Essential$2.35$44.85

Rent of $2,500

AppACHCard
Innago$2.00$74.75
RentRedi$1.00$77.80
Baselane$2.00$87.25
Buildium Essential$2.35$74.75

What the Gap Costs Over a Year

For one unit at $1,500, paid monthly:

App12 ACH payments12 card paymentsDifference
RentRedi$12.00$561.60$549.60
Innago$24.00$538.20$514.20
Baselane$24.00$628.20$604.20

Whoever pays the fee carries that difference. By default that is the tenant on Innago, RentRedi, and TenantCloud. On Baselane the ACH fee goes to the landlord or the tenant, and the card fee goes to the tenant.

What the Landlord Receives

When a landlord covers the fee, the app deducts it from the payment. RentRedi's help page gives the example: a tenant pays $100 from a bank account, the $1 ACH fee is deducted, and the landlord receives $99. On a $1,500 card payment on RentRedi with the landlord covering the fee, the landlord receives $1,453.20.

Four Ways to Keep Payment Fees Low

  1. Make ACH the default. RentRedi's help page marks ACH as the recommended method.
  2. Turn on autopay. RentRedi, Baselane, and TenantCloud list autopay on their pages.
  3. Decide who covers the fee. Covering a $1 or $2 ACH fee is a small cost. Covering a card fee on a $1,500 rent is $44.85 or more.
  4. Check card settings. RentRedi lets a landlord disable card payments and accept ACH only.

Try RentRedi: RentRedi website

Try Innago: Innago website

The Formula

Card fee = rent × percentage + any flat amount.

For a $1,750 rent on RentRedi: $1,750 × 0.031 + $0.30 = $54.55.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who pays the fee when a tenant pays rent online?

On Innago, RentRedi, and TenantCloud the tenant pays by default, and Innago and RentRedi let the landlord take it on. Baselane's ACH fee is the landlord's or the tenant's, by choice.

Are debit cards charged the same as credit cards?

Yes, on the three apps that say so. RentRedi's help page lists 3.1% + $0.30 for credit and debit cards. Baselane lists 3.49% for both. Innago lists 2.99% for credit and debit cards together.

Do these fees change?

Yes. A script re-reads these pages every week, and this guide is updated when a fee changes.

Sources

Landlord Grid provides general information about software and fees.